Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The video shows a rotating camera at the top of the car that's scanning for objects (I guess). What's the advantage of a mechanical rotary movement over an array of cameras that give a continuous 360 degree view (e.g. the street view cars)?

Update : Found a link : http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2402516,00.asp In an interview last week, Stuart Woods, the executive vice president of Velodyne, which manufactures the LIDAR (Light Detection And Ranging) rotating module that sits atop Google's autonomous vehicles, said that his company has started developing prototype security systems that could be trialed within the next year. The Velodyne LIDAR HDL-64E and HDL-32E modules use an array of either 64 or 32 lasers to electronically "see" the environment, Woods said. On Google's car, the module is set inside a rotating drum. Its lasers complement Google's own mapping software and GPS data, which help orient the car on the road. The LIDAR provides additional positional data, but also identifies other cars, bicycles, pedestrians, and road hazards.



If I'm not mistaken, the "camera" at the top sends a very thin, concentrated vertical beam to detect objects. To implement it in the way you described, you'd need quite a few cameras (100+) to get the same precision.


I don't know why they chose it, but off the top of my head :

1) possibly less production cost. an individual laser module is likely more costly than the mechanism to rotate a single one.

2) fewer channels of data often means less processing overhead.


Don't think of it as a camera. Think of it as a radar (that uses laser light instead of radio waves, hence the LI instead of RA in LIDAR).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: