Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That response from manjuraj was kind of evil


Has open source changed? I remember when people didn't fork projects, rebadge them as there own and then promote them over the original.

Now don't get me wrong, I think its amazing that Twitter are opening up these enhancements to the community, but it feels like a kick in the teeth to the memcached folks to slap a twitter badge on it, why isn't this a collaboration that benefits the whole community? you know, like open source used to work.

I know at 34 I'm a dinosaur in this industry but I do try to keep up with the new way of doing things... This just feels wrong to me.


I think open source has changed a bit with the rise of the GitHub era. IMHO, I think @mikeal did a good post regarding this change "Apache considered harmful" http://www.mikealrogers.com/posts/apache-considered-harmful....

Even in the old days, it's easier to fork than work with upstream. I think these days it's just easier share those forks with services like GitHub. It should help spread ideas and improved solutions IMHO so downstream consumers actually benefit.

In Twitter's case, they are planning to do what works for them at the moment: "While we initially focused on the challenging goal of making Memcached work extremely well within the Twitter infrastructure, we look forward to sharing our code and ideas with the Memcached community in the long term."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: