Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I would question all these Raspberry PI-ish NAS attempts, especially when it includes some power adapters and milling out cases. It all feels so fiddly and sluggish while still being "not that cheap". Storing my important personal data on an USB-drive somewhat feels risky. It probably wouldn't burn a house down, but still...

The real benefit is the small form factor and the "low" power consumption. Paying 43 bucks for the whole thing - now asking myself if it is worth saving a few bucks and living with 100Mbit network speed, instead of spending 150 bucks and having 2.5Gig.

There are so many (also "used") alternatives out there:

- Fujitsu Futro S920 (used < 75, ~10W)

- FriendlyElec NanoPI R6C (< 150, ~2W, https://www.friendlyelec.com/index.php?route=product/product...)

- FriendlyElec Nas Kit (< 150, ~5W, https://www.friendlyelec.com/index.php?route=product/product...)

- Dell T20 / T30 (used < 100, ~25W)

- Fujitsu Celsius W570 (used < 100, ~15W)

My personal NAS / Homeserver:

  Fujitsu D3417-B
  Intel Xeon 1225v5
  64GB ECC RAM
  WD SN850x 2TB NVMe
  Pico PSU 120
  
More expensive, but reliable, powerful and drawing <10W Idle.


You are comparing apple and oranges: the SBC used by the author has a consumption of 0.75W idle and 4W Full load


No I don't. The FriendlyElec NanoPI R6C can be brought to 1W Idle including NVMe SSD and 2.5GBe (and REAL transfer rates of >200MB/s). It's more expensive, but totally worth it in my opinion. See https://www.hardwareluxx.de/community/threads/ultra-low-powe...

Since it has neither ECC nor support for common Open Source NAS Operating Systems, I still would not buy it as my daily driver. I just don't think that a difference of 5W Idle Power is worth the effort of milling out stuff, using USB-Storage and the additional maintenance effort keeping this system up to date.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: