Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If we're talking about US politics, there's also the tendency of the right to cluster to a common narrative, whereas the left tends to be more tolerant of diverse narratives.

It would seem unsurprising that the end result of this, upon pulling the "center" of each party towards its own extreme, is essentially what we've seen -- ~50% of conservatives now believe in vaccine/pandemic conspiracy theories, vs liberals support some extremists at the local level, but also continue to support centrists like Biden at the national level.



> It would seem unsurprising that the end result of this, upon pulling the "center" of each party towards its own extreme, is essentially what we've seen -- ~50% of conservatives now believe in vaccine/pandemic conspiracy theories, vs liberals support some extremists at the local level

They wouldn't be pulled to extremes, they'd already be there. However, most research shows it's the right that's moved far. Look at Trumpism and compare that to prior conservative leaders, such as GW Bush, GHW Bush, Reagan, Ford .... Biden fits right in with Clinton and Obama.

> liberals support some extremists at the local level

What extremists? There are people farther left than Biden, but nobody trying to seize power from the people, letting a deadly pandemic spread for political reasons, backing arrest and brutality toward their political enemies, etc.

It's not balanced; if Amy punches Bob, it's not even-handed to blame both of them. If Amy burns down the house, it's not even-handed to say 'we're all crazy'.


> already be there

I see Trumpism as a cause, not a symptom.

The right was casting about for a leader after McCain and Romney (both centrists) lost to Obama. Trump (and allies) spoke loudest, and so pulled the "party truth" to the right for the Republican party.

Those Republicans who disagreed (of whom there were many) left politics or stopped speaking publicly about their disagreement. Or, over time, began to agree with the party line. Little tent politics.

> What extremists?

There's a well known group, who you can probably find by seeing who's on the Fox News homepage right now, who says things would would be considered far left.

And yet, Biden still calls these people crazy and says no to the more extreme policy proposals. Big tent politics.

My comment wasn't sharing blame. It was remarking on the fundamentally different organizations that the right and the left run, and who they allow to speak.


> My comment wasn't sharing blame. It was remarking on the fundamentally different organizations that the right and the left run, and who they allow to speak.

Fair enough, and I think that's a valuable point. However, I think the following is too:

>> What extremists?

> There's a well known group, who you can probably find by seeing who's on the Fox News homepage right now, who says things would would be considered far left.

> And yet, Biden still calls these people crazy and says no to the more extreme policy proposals. Big tent politics.

I don't think they are extremists, but if you can name some and their extreme policies, I'd go with it. Fox isn't a great source for deciding what is 'far left'.


I've got a bit of a thing about naming politicians below singular offices. It seems like part of the problem: name recognition wins elections and donations.

But to talk about policies, I would call defunding all police, complete student loan forgiveness, banning nuclear power and crude exports, and opposing market based carbon taxes extremist.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: