Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Population management is a bigger part of the solution than pipes and dams.

"Population management" is a road leading straight to ethical catastrophes, to murder and other horrible forms of suffering. There have been many of these - genocides, "Lebensraum im Osten" aka Nazi Germany invading Eastern Europe, the Holocaust, China's "1 child policy".

The best way a society can handle population management is fact-based sex education and safe, cheap access to contraceptives and medical abortion, and general access to healthcare and a social security network so that people don't have to have half a dozen children if they want one or two to survive to adulthood and care for them at old age.



Are you sure you’re disagreeing with the parent poster? It sounds to me like you’ve just outlined a plan to achieve the same goal.


The parent poster advocated for a one-child policy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25372090


> "Population management" is a road leading

You can say that about anything: socialist policies, "no-tolerance" policies, anything that looks like censorship.

You say there have been many such example, then trot out Nazi Germany; The fact the Nazis purposefully initiated a genocide (the holocaust) out of hatred out the Jews undermines the suggestion that there was a genuine attempt at population management.

Chinas also has a pretty poor human rights example, aside from it's 1-child policy.

Do you have any example of a modern (first-world, developed) country with a good human-rights record, and QOL index pursuing population management?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: