Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Almost no one actually audits the source they download before they run it,

Thats not the security issue here, its effectively running build-time logic during install-time, on every bodies machine at every install, instead of at package maintainers secure build system, once, and having the installation basically be an unpack instruction.

Another negative point of curl | bash, is you assume your users are idiots who do not know their OS package manager well enough to run apt-get install shitpackage pacman -S shitpackage or apk add shitpackage.



> Another negative point of curl | bash, is you assume your users are idiots who do not know their OS package manager well enough to run apt-get install shitpackage pacman -S shitpackage or apk add shitpackage.

Absolutely, but packaging for all major distributions can be a larger headache than writing the project in the first place. For a lot of small projects, this isn't justifiable.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: